The SS Defiance Found Standing Upright on the Sea Floor

The SS Defiance Found Standing Upright on the Sea Floor
Photo: Art Institute of Chicago

In 1918, a large wooden ship called the Defiance sank to the bottom of Lake Huron after a crash in deep fog. Most ships that sink break into pieces or lie flat on their side in the dark water. But when divers finally found the Defiance, the ship was sitting perfectly upright on the cold lake floor, looking like it was still waiting to sail away.

This is the true story of how a heavy schooner dropped over a hundred feet through pitch-black water and landed on its keel without falling over. It stayed hidden for nearly ninety years, preserved in the icy water just off the coast of Michigan. Today, it remains one of the most unbelievable sights underwater anywhere in the world.

The Terrible Collision in the Lake Huron Fog

The night of October 20, 1918, was freezing and dark. The Defiance was a wooden schooner measuring over one hundred feet long, loaded heavy with grain. It was moving slowly through the thick fog on Lake Huron, heading south toward the city of Port Huron. The crew could barely see the bow of their own ship, let alone another vessel coming toward them.

At the exact same time, another heavy ship named the John J. Barlum was moving north through the same fog. Neither ship had modern radar or radio equipment. They had to rely on kerosene lamps and hand-cranked fog horns. By the time the watchman on the Defiance heard the horn of the Barlum, it was too late to turn.

The Barlum slammed straight into the side of the Defiance. The wooden planks cracked like gunshots, tearing a huge hole into the side of the hull. Water poured into the hold at an alarming rate. The captain of the Defiance knew his ship was doomed, so he ordered his men into the small wooden lifeboat immediately.

All four crew members scrambled into the small boat just as their heavy ship slipped under the surface. They rowed through the freezing mist for hours until they finally made it to shore. They were alive, but their beloved ship was gone, swallowed up by Lake Huron in less than fifteen minutes.

The SS Defiance Found Standing Upright on the Sea Floor
Photo: Art Institute of Chicago

Why Did the Defiance Land Standing Upright?

When a ship sinks into deep water, it almost always flips over or crashes into the mud on its side. The heavy wooden masts usually break off, and the hull splits open when it hits the bottom. So, how did the Defiance end up sitting perfectly straight, as if it were docked at a pier?

Scientists and deep-sea divers spent years studying the site to figure out what happened. The secret lies in the weight of the ship and the air trapped inside its wooden frame. As the Defiance filled with water, its heavy iron keel pointed straight down toward the lake floor like a giant plumb bob.

At the same time, the wooden decks and masts still had trapped air bubbles that wanted to float up. This created a natural balance. The bottom of the ship was extremely heavy, while the top of the ship was light and buoyant. It was like a toy punch-bag that always stands back up no matter how hard you push it down.

The ship drifted down through 185 feet of water, staying straight the entire way down. When it finally reached the bottom, the keel slid gently into the soft mud. The shock was soft enough that the masts stayed put. If you want to read another strange tale about impossible connections, check out The Twins Separated at Birth Who Lived the Same Life.

Lost in the Dark for Almost Ninety Years

For decades, local fishermen knew the story of the Defiance, but nobody knew where it lay. Lake Huron covers more than twenty-three thousand square miles. Finding a single wooden ship on the lake bed is like looking for a lost needle in a massive haystack.

Over the years, many hunters tried and failed to locate the wreck. The lake is famous for its fierce storms, icy cold temperatures, and pitch-black water. Equipment broke, storms blew in, and search teams ran out of money. The Defiance became a legend, a ghost ship that people talked about in local taverns along the coast.

Then, in the summer of 2004, a famous shipwreck hunter named Pat Stayer decided to try a new search area. He used side-scan sonar, a device towed behind a boat that bounces sound waves off the lake floor to build a picture of the bottom. After days of seeing nothing but flat mud, his screens suddenly showed a strange shape.

It was a long, dark shadow sitting right in the middle of a flat plain of mud. The sonar picture did not look like a broken pile of wood. It looked like a full ship, standing upright with two tall poles reaching toward the surface. Stayer could hardly believe his eyes. He dropped an anchor mark and prepared his dive team.

What Divers Saw When They Swam Down

Diving to 185 feet in Lake Huron is not a simple swim. The water at that depth stays around thirty-eight degrees Fahrenheit all year long. It is completely black, so divers must bring powerful underwater lights. They can only stay down for a few minutes before they have to come back up slowly to avoid getting sick.

When the first diver dropped down the anchor line, he passed through layers of murky green water. At a hundred feet, all daylight disappeared. He turned on his dive torch, cutting a narrow beam through the black void. Then, out of the darkness, something incredible appeared.

It was the tip of a wooden mast. As the diver swam deeper, he saw the second mast, standing straight up. He followed the wood down to the deck. There sat the Defiance, perfectly whole. The wooden wheel was still in place. The anchor was still stowed on the deck. The ship looked as fresh as the day it sank in 1918.

Because Lake Huron is freezing cold and fresh, there are no ocean worms to eat the wood. The cold water acts like a natural freezer. The ropes were still coiled on the deck, and the wooden grain hatches were still closed tight. It was like stepping straight back into a frozen moment in history.

How Do Ships Stay Saved for So Long?

Many people wonder why ships in the Great Lakes look so much better than ships found in the ocean. If a ship sinks in the Atlantic Ocean, saltwater eats away the metal parts, and wood-boring worms destroy the timbers in a few years. Within a century, almost nothing is left except cannons and stone ballast.

The Great Lakes are completely fresh water, which changes everything. There are no salt crystals to break down the wood and no shipworms to chew through the beams. The cold water slows down rot to a crawl. In fact, many wooden ships in Lake Huron look like they sank last week instead of a century ago.

If you enjoy reading a good Human-interest story about real people and wild historical events, this shipwreck is a prime example. The sailors who lost their ship in 1918 never dreamed that people in the twenty-first century would swim down and look at their wooden wheel, untouched by time.

Recently, tiny mussels called zebra mussels have invaded the Great Lakes. They coat the wood in a hard layer of shells. While these mussels make the water super clear, they also cover up small details on the wood. Divers are working hard to film and map the Defiance before the mussels cover every inch of its surface.

Visiting the Underwater Time Capsule Today

Today, the Defiance is protected by federal law as part of an underwater preserve. Technical divers from around the world travel to Michigan just to swim down and see it with their own eyes. But it is not a place for beginners. The depth and cold make it a risky dive that requires special gas mixtures and long safety stops.

Those who make it down describe it as a spiritual experience. Imagine swimming along a wooden deck where sailors walked during World War I. You can look right into the cabin quarters. You can see the huge wooden bowsprit pointing forward into the dark water, still heading south toward a port it never reached.

Local museums near Lake Huron display photographs and sonar scans of the ship for people who cannot dive that deep. If you like historical tales, check out our latest posts on the main page of our true stories blog to find more strange tales from around the globe.

The story of the Defiance reminds us of how mysterious the deep water can be. A hundred feet below the waves, history is sitting completely still, waiting in the dark. It makes you think about what else might be hiding on the bottom of the world's lakes and oceans, just sitting there right side up, waiting for someone to find it.

Have you ever seen a real historical shipwreck up close, or would you ever dive down into the dark water to see one? Next time you stand on the shore of a large lake, remember that there might be a whole ship standing beneath the waves right in front of you.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Man Who Survived Two Atomic Bombs

How Tsutomu Yamaguchi Survived Two Atomic Bombs in Three Days

The Pilot Who Landed a Plane on a River and Saved Everyone